III · Making it pay · Topic 5

Bringing your customers over

14 min

This is the topic that decides whether any of the rest mattered. Buying the system takes an afternoon. Changing where a customer taps on a Friday night takes months, and it is the part almost every restaurant skips. An ordering page nobody knows about is a monthly bill, not a channel.

🧲 Where your first direct customers come from

Not from strangers. Your first hundred direct orders come from people who already eat your food, in roughly this order of ease:

  1. People sitting in your restaurant right now. The cheapest audience you will ever have, and the one most restaurants never ask.
  2. People picking up a marketplace order. They are standing at your counter. They already like you enough to be there.
  3. People who follow you already on whatever social account you have.
  4. People who call to order. Every phone order is someone who wanted to order direct and did it the hard way.

Nothing on that list requires an advertising budget. All of it requires somebody remembering to mention it, which is a training problem, not a marketing one.

📣 The moves that actually work

  • A card in every bag. Including marketplace bags. Your link, and one specific reason: same prices as the restaurant, a free side on the first direct order, something not on the app.
  • A table tent or a line on the check. Someone who just enjoyed a meal is the most receptive audience for "next time, order direct".
  • Train the phone answer. "I can take that now — and next time you can order from our site, it takes a minute." Every phone order is a conversion opportunity delivered to you.
  • Your Google listing. Google Business Profile lets you set your own ordering link. Many restaurants leave it pointing at a marketplace by default. Check yours today; it is free and it is a lot of traffic.
  • Social bio and posts. Not "we have online ordering" — a photo of the food with the link and a reason.
  • Email, if you have a list. The highest-converting channel by a wide margin, and one you own outright.

⚖️ What your contract may forbid

Before you print anything, read your marketplace agreement. Some contain clauses about steering customers away, and a few restaurants have learned about them the expensive way.

  • Generally fine: your own branding and link on your own packaging, your own website, your own social accounts, your own emails, telling a customer in your restaurant.
  • Check the contract: inserts placed inside a marketplace order, and any language that disparages the platform.
  • Never: anything untrue about the platform's fees or service.

The safe version needs no comparison at all: say what ordering direct gets the customer. You do not have to attack the marketplace to give someone a reason.

🎁 One good offer beats five weak ones

You need a reason to switch that survives being said in one sentence. Options, roughly best first:

OfferWhy it worksWhat it costs you
Same price as the restaurantTrue every time, no expiry, no margin given awayNothing
Free side or drink, first direct orderConcrete, once, and low food costA dollar or two, once per customer
Something only available directGives a reason that a discount cannot copyKitchen complexity
A loyalty stamp per direct orderBuilds the habit rather than buying one orderNeeds a system to run it
Percentage off every direct orderSimple — and permanently gives away the advantage you just gainedThe point of the exercise

Pick one, say it everywhere, and give it a year. Switching offers every month teaches customers to wait rather than to change.

Answer in your own words, JP gives feedback and a progress score.